faraclit,
Nice rationalization but your dog won't hunt.
Yau and those who agree with Yau are correct. No matter how convoluted and pseudo intellectual a bad science excuse for a misconception is…it is nevertheless…bad science. I read a reply by somebody princes where she misunderstood the question,..”can God build a rock so big he can’t pick it up?”. Is a loaded question which is meant to disprove an assumption by religious soothsayers centuries ago that the concept of omnipotence is a valid concept. The concept is invalid and the question is the proof.
Einstein said it best. After spending two hours trying to explain relativistic concepts to a science writer witnessed the frustrated writer place her pad and pen on her latp and ask with confusion…”Well, what is real then?”
Einstein realizing that further attempts to explain were fruitless said, and this is the answer about God or any other unproven idea conceived of mankind,
“Vell, I suppose zat fur mosd peoples, it ist a matter of perception, Ja?”
So God is real if you perceive God to be real and, for that matter, so is Spiderman., an honest politician, a dog with an elephant’s head and bible thumpers who will actually listen to a contrasting point of view. lol
|